What Motivates Nonprofit Giving? Attitudes, Not Demographics

Nonprofit marketing strategist Jane Pfeiffer next to text that reads, Nonprofit Marketing Strategist Jane Pfeiffer Identifies What Motivates and Influences Giving When Demographics Cant.

Most nonprofits know their donors by age, zip code, and giving history. Almost none know why those donors give.

That gap is expensive. It’s why one appeal lands with some and is ignored by most.

Jane Pfeiffer and the Fieldtrip team set out to measure it. Here is what they found.

Quick answer: Fieldtrip’s Beyond Donor Demos study of 400 U.S. nonprofit supporters found that donors sort into three roughly equal, attitude-based segments, empathetic, skeptical, and disconnected, and that gender, age, household income, and location were consistent across all three.

What motivates and influences giving is how a supporter thinks about their reasons to give, whether a solution is possible, and whether people deserve help. Each segment needs a different message, and demographics alone can’t identify them.

What Motivates and Influences Giving When Demographics Can’t?

Attitudes do. Fieldtrip’s research shows that a supporter’s beliefs about why they give, whether progress is possible, and who deserves help predict their response to an appeal far better than any demographic profile. Jane Pfeiffer walks through the four findings that matter most below.

1. The Biggest Expense in a Nonprofit Is One That Never Shows Up on the Ledger

The greatest cost a purpose-driven organization carries is lost opportunity, and Jane names the cause: IDKs.

“An IDK is an ‘I don’t know,’” Jane says. “I don’t know you. I don’t know why your mission matters, or how solving this social issue affects my life. Those IDKs create the cost of lost opportunities.”

Anyone who could have supported the mission with time, money, skills, or introductions but didn’t may have had an IDK standing in the way. They may not say it out loud, but that lack of understanding keeps them from getting involved. When people with the resources to help don’t opt in, the mission loses opportunities to make a difference.

Your highest cost is the mission-driven work you could do but can’t because you lack sufficient, sustainable funding.

2. Attitudinal Segmentation Asks Why People Give, and Demographics Never Will

Attitudinal segmentation groups supporters by their motivations, beliefs, and perceptions rather than by age, income, location, or giving history. Jane explains it with a story from Fieldtrip’s research partner and a national upscale candle company.

The candle manufacturer targeted women 25 to 54 with above-average household income who owned their home. That profile described millions of people and said nothing about why they bought it.  When the company sorted buyers by attitude instead, three groups appeared:

  1. Self-appreciation buyers cared about fragrance and purchased candles in stores where they could sample the scents.
  2. Designers selected candles based on how they finished the room’s decor and may never light them.
  3. Gift buyers focused on the luxurious packaging.

The first application of the attitudinal findings was to target the self-appreciation segment by adding scratch-and-sniff strips in the catalog. This one change returned roughly three times the prior response from the same group. “It’s focusing on the why behind the decision to buy or the decision to support, rather than the what, how, or demographic characteristics,” Jane says. The same logic applies to first-time, lapsed, and recurring donor labels. Those characteristics tell you what someone did. They don’t tell you why or what to say next.

Demographics tell you who gave. Attitudes tell you why and what to say to them next.

3. The Study Found Three Supporter Segments and No Demographic Difference Between Them

Fieldtrip commissioned original quantitative research with 400 participants from across the United States. Every respondent had donated to, volunteered for, or raised funds for a social welfare nonprofit. The margin of error is plus or minus 4.9% at a 95% confidence level. Of everyone who started the survey, about one third qualified as a supporter, meaning about two-thirds did not identify as nonprofit supporters.

What surprises people the most is what the segments do not share. “One of the biggest takeaways is there was no significant difference in the three groups in demographics,” Jane says. Gender, age, household income, and urban, suburban, or rural location were consistent across all three.

What separates the groups is how they think about three things: their motivation to give, their belief that solutions are possible for the issues nonprofits address, and their view of the mission recipients. The segments split roughly into thirds:

  • Empathetic supporters take personal responsibility for making a difference, often come from a family culture of giving, believe solutions are possible with enough commitment and resources, and believe everyone deserves help regardless of past choices. They want a role, not just a receipt.
  • Skeptical supporters give for external reasons, because friends and family admire them for it, and because of guilt and pity. They tend to believe that needing help usually results from bad choices, that the people nonprofits serve are very different from them, and that there is a limit to how much help someone deserves. They care most that their money is not misused.
  • Disconnected supporters worry about the state of the world and believe everyone can change, but doubt that complex problems can actually be solved. They believe each person is always responsible for their own decisions, and 80% say they are as empathetic toward others as ever, or less so.

Jane is careful on one point: “Remember, all three of these are supporters, so any category is of interest to us.”

If your donor list looks like our study, about a third wants to be your champion, a third wants proof their money won’t be wasted, and a third doubts the problem can be solved. One message can’t speak to all three beliefs.

4. Each Segment Needs a Different Message, and the Goal Is Not to Convert One Into Another

Fieldtrip demonstrated how the same human story should change by segment. For empathetic supporters, a first-person emotional testimonial and a direct ask is enough, because they already believe the best about the people being served. For skeptical supporters, the story needs context. Jane’s advice is to share stories from the people you serve without sugarcoating them, and to make it clear that it is not just one bad decision that led to the suffering. For disconnected supporters, the story needs layers: how one person’s recovery affects her children, her employer, her neighborhood, and the town’s resources, because this group explores before it gives and wants proof of progress.

What encourages a gift also differs. Empathetic supporters respond to human stories, meet with recipients, attend fundraising events, and respond to round-up prompts, and 57% report contact with the organization more than twice a year. Disconnected supporters want transparency before they give: an organization free from scandal, focused on local issues and prevention, and spending as much as possible on direct aid. Skeptical supporters do less homework up front and want assurance after the gift about how the money was used.

Asked whether a nonprofit should try to move a skeptical or disconnected supporter into the empathetic group, Jane says no. “These attitudes and beliefs are rooted in who they were as younger people, who they’ve been surrounded with, and their exposure to complex social issues,” she says. “It’s more about inviting and getting closer to all three of these groups, as opposed to trying to switch people from one group to another.”

The practical relief for a small team: messaging built for the skeptical and disconnected segments does not turn off the empathetic supporter. Messaging built only for the empathetic supporter, Jane notes, “may not be enough” for the other two.

Meet each segment where it already stands. Write for the hardest group to convince, and the easiest will come along.

The Three Supporter Segments at a Glance

Donor supporter types
Attribute Empathetic Supporter Skeptical Supporter Disconnected Supporter
Why they give A sense of personal responsibility to make a difference, often shaped by a family culture of giving. Friends and family admire them for it. Guilt and pity are present. Concern about the state of the world.
Belief in a solution Solutions are possible, even for the most complex issues, with enough people, commitment, and resources. Needing help from a nonprofit usually results from bad choices. Progress matters and everyone can change, but the most pressing problems may never be solved.
View of the people served Everyone deserves help regardless of past decisions. It could be any of us, and helping later in life is as worthwhile as helping earlier. The people being served are very different from them, bring their challenges on themselves, and there is a limit to how much help someone deserves. Each person is always responsible for their own decisions. Some people will never get out of bad circumstances no matter how much help they receive.
What they want from you A meaningful role, high-touch contact, and the tools to advocate. Assurance after the gift that the money was not misused. Less interest in researching the organization beforehand. Proof before the gift: an organization free from scandal, focused on local issues and prevention, spending as much as possible on direct aid.
Message that works A first-person emotional testimonial plus a direct ask. The same story with context showing causes outside the person’s control, told without sugarcoating. Layered impact, from the person to their family, their employer, and the community. Guilt is a turnoff.
Engagement focus Make it easy for these supporters to turn into active champions. Transparency about the context of the issue, its impact, your outcomes, and the obstacles you and the people you serve face. Honest, simple stories with layers they can opt into.

One Story, Three Messages: How Fieldtrip Rewrites the Same Appeal for Each Segment

Jane uses a single participant, a woman she calls Sally, who went through a recovery program, to show how little the facts change and how much the framing does. The three versions below are drawn from the webinar.

For the empathetic supporter. Lead with Sally in her own words: the organization saved her life; without its services, she wouldn’t be on the path to recovery, and her kids would be homeless; and getting connected wasn’t just luck, it was a miracle. Then share: your dollars create brighter futures for women in our community. Learn how supporters like you drive Sally’s success. No context is needed because this reader already believes the best about Sally.

For the skeptical supporter. Give the why before the ask. Any of us could lose our jobs. For Sally, losing her job meant losing her home and escaping her anxiety through addiction. The recovery program brought her back from the brink, and now she is one of many graduates. Learn how we support women in need and turn bad luck into bright futures. The job loss and outcomes data do the work here, because this reader needs to see that Sally’s situation wasn’t simply the result of a bad choice.

For the disconnected supporter. Widen the frame from Sally to the town. Substance abuse is costly for the participant and for the community’s resources. The nonprofit’s proven methods stretch the town’s resources further and deliver lasting recovery. Your gift supports Sally’s return to independence and creates stability for her and her children. That’s a win for Sally, her family, her employer, and our community. Learn why investing in Sally is investing in our community. This reader will explore before deciding, so the invitation is to learn, and the proof is the ripple effect.

Same Sally. Same program. Three different reasons to care.

What You Will Learn From the Webinar

  • The hidden cost of lost opportunities: Why Fieldtrip defines “IDKs” (lack of awareness and connection) as a nonprofit’s largest expense.
  • Attitudinal segmentation: How focusing on three donor motivations rather than demographics moves potential donors closer to a gift.
  • Segment-specific messaging techniques: How to tailor a story to speak directly to each donor attitude.

How to Apply Attitudinal Segmentation to Your Supporter Base

  1. Start with why, not what. Before writing any piece, ask why this group will care, rather than what you want to tell them. Jane calls this the single most powerful takeaway if you do nothing else.
  2. Assign each communication to a segment. Your impact report is for the disconnected supporter, who wants proof before investing. Short, photo-led social stories are for the empathetic supporter. Events, where people are seen with the right people, are where you meet the skeptical supporter. You cannot produce three of everything, so decide who each piece serves and carve out a section for the others.
  3. Write for the harder segments. Context and outcomes written for skeptical and disconnected supporters do not deter empathetic supporters. Messaging written only for the empathetic may not reach the other two.
  4. Rotate the stories you tell. Reusing the same person or family dilutes the story and hides how many people the mission has helped. Tell new stories, and make clear what was outside the person’s control.
  5. Layer the impact. For every story, write the next ring out: family, children’s schooling and housing, employer, neighborhood, community. That is the version disconnected supporters need.
  6. Give empathetic supporters a role. They already have advocacy in their DNA. Give them the tools, information, and confidence to recruit, and ask them to.
  7. Survey your database. Segments don’t correlate with demographics, so the only way to know your mix is to ask. Fieldtrip can run its segmentation profile against a supporter list. Demographics are still useful alongside attitudes; for example, a lapsed empathetic donor may have lapsed because they stopped feeling they had a role.
  8. Interrupt to reach non-supporters. Email, social, and events only reach people already in your orbit. Roughly two-thirds who do not consider themselves supporters likely share the same three attitudes, but you will reach them only through earned media, paid advertising, or boosted posts that spark curiosity in their spaces.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is attitudinal segmentation for nonprofits?

Attitudinal segmentation groups supporters by their motivations, beliefs, and perceptions about a cause rather than by demographics or giving history. In Fieldtrip’s Beyond Donor Demos research, Jane Pfeiffer sorts supporters by three attitudes: why they give, whether they believe a solution is possible, and how they view the people a nonprofit serves. Those attitudes, not age or income, determine which message moves a supporter to act.

What are the three donor segments in Fieldtrip’s research?

Fieldtrip found three supporter segments: empathetic, skeptical, and disconnected, each roughly one third of the supporter population. Empathetic supporters take personal responsibility for making a difference and believe everyone deserves help. Skeptical supporters give because others admire them for it and doubt that the people nonprofits serve deserve or genuinely need help. Disconnected supporters care about the world but doubt that complex problems can be solved and hold individuals responsible for their circumstances.

Do donor demographics predict giving?

Not in Fieldtrip’s study. Across 400 U.S. supporters, gender, age, household income, and urban, suburban, or rural location were consistent across all three attitude segments. Jane Pfeiffer concludes that demographics describe who gave, while attitudes explain why, and only the why tells a nonprofit what to say next.

Can a nonprofit turn a skeptical or disconnected supporter into an empathetic one?

Jane Pfeiffer does not consider that a reasonable goal. These attitudes are rooted in a person’s upbringing, the people around them, and their exposure to complex social issues. Fieldtrip recommends meeting each segment where it is, building an emotional connection, sparking curiosity, and bringing all three groups closer to the organization, rather than trying to move people between groups.

How should a nonprofit message skeptical donors?

Give context before the ask. Skeptical supporters are more likely to believe the people being served brought their challenges on themselves, so the story must show what was outside the person’s control, share outcomes honestly without sugarcoating, and avoid reusing the same person. After the gift, they want assurance about how the money was used more than they want to research the organization beforehand.

How do you create empathy in disconnected supporters?

When Fieldtrip asked, disconnected respondents said you cannot; empathy comes from within and isn’t the organization’s job to create. In Jane Pfeiffer’s analysis, what works is honest, simple stories with layers that show how solving a problem for one person ripples out to their family, employer, and community, plus transparency about progress before they are asked to give. Guilt is a turnoff for this group.

Should a nonprofit message all three segments at once or separately?

Both, within what a small team can manage. Jane Pfeiffer’s advice is to decide which segment each communication piece best serves (the impact report for disconnected supporters, brief emotional social stories for empathetic supporters, events for skeptical supporters) and then carve out sections within each piece that speak to the other two. Messaging aimed at the skeptical and disconnected does not turn off the empathetic.

Continue the Conversation

The webinar is the foundation. These Fieldtrip Journal pieces pick up where it leaves off.

Research Notes and Sources

Every figure in this article comes from the sources below. Where a claim is Jane Pfeiffer’s interpretation rather than a published number, it is labeled.

Beyond Donor Demos: Leverage Attitudes Over Demographics for Nonprofits. Original quantitative research commissioned by Fieldtrip and conducted with its research partner. 400 participants from across the United States, each of whom had donated to, volunteered for, or raised funds for a social welfare nonprofit. Margin of error: plus or minus 4.9% at a 95% confidence level. Findings presented by Jane Pfeiffer in the “Leveraging Donor Empathy” webinar, February 2024.

The full data visualization is available here.

Figures stated in the webinar and used in this article:

  • Three segments split “nearly a third, a third, a third” (the published chart totals 101% due to rounding).
  • No statistically significant demographic differences (gender, age, household income, urban/suburban/rural) across the three segments.
  • About one third of survey respondents identified as nonprofit supporters.
  • 57% of empathetic supporters reported contact with the organization more than twice a year.
  • 80% of disconnected supporters feel the same or less empathetic toward others than ever before.

Candle company case (attitudinal segmentation illustration). A true story from Fieldtrip’s research partner’s work with a national upscale candle company. The “3x return” figure is as Jane stated it in the webinar for the self-appreciation segment after adding scratch-and-sniff strips to the catalog. The company is not named.

2025 Edelman Trust Barometer, cited in Fieldtrip’s “Building Trust in a Climate of Active Distrust”, 61% of people globally report moderate or high grievance toward government, business, and nonprofits; 40% would support hostile activism.

Lincoln Foundation outcome ($100,000 grant after changing its introduction), from Fieldtrip’s Unapologetic Fundraising series, Episode 3 (January 31, 2026). Client story told by Fieldtrip.

About Jane Pfeiffer

Jane Pfeiffer is the Founder and President of Fieldtrip, a cause-driven marketing agency in Louisville, Kentucky, that helps nonprofits multiply their missions. A former research marketing specialist in television, Jane started Fieldtrip with a single client and now leads a team serving organizations nationwide in public and private education, homelessness, child abuse prevention, LGBTQIA+ advocacy, substance use disorder, and other health and social services. She presents Fieldtrip’s Mission Multiplier video series and created its Unapologetic Fundraising program. Connect with Jane on LinkedIn or at wearefieldtrip.com.

About Fieldtrip

Fieldtrip is a cause-driven marketing agency based in Louisville, Kentucky, that helps nonprofits multiply their missions. Its tagline is “United We Create.” Its values are Curiosity, Impact, Spirit, and Candor. Fieldtrip’s work includes positioning and messaging, fundraising strategy and campaigns, brand strategy and identity, accessibility-first websites, and marketing and communications, delivered through a five-step process: Survey, Envision, Make, Deploy, Measure. Fieldtrip publishes original research and the Mission Multiplier series to help nonprofit leaders find what motivates and influences their supporters.

Key Moments in the Webinar

  • 00:00 Welcome from Andrew Spalding, Creative Director, and Jane Pfeiffer, Founder and President
  • 00:28 The cost of IDKs: why lost opportunity is a nonprofit’s largest expense
  • 02:11 Why Fieldtrip commissioned quantitative research on supporter attitudes
  • 02:56 Attitudinal segmentation explained through a national candle company
  • 07:43 Study design: 400 U.S. supporters, margin of error, and the demographic finding
  • 09:28 Meet the three segments: empathetic, skeptical, disconnected
  • 10:04 The empathetic supporter: beliefs, triggers, and the advocacy opportunity
  • 14:35 Messaging example for empathetic supporters
  • 15:19 The skeptical supporter: external motivators, guilt, pity, and post-gift assurance
  • 18:24 Messaging example for skeptical supporters
  • 20:04 The disconnected supporter: concern without belief in a solution
  • 24:15 “You can’t create empathy”: what disconnected respondents said
  • 25:04 Messaging example for disconnected supporters
  • 26:00 How to apply the research: why before what, closing the empathy gap, assessing your database
  • 29:35 Q&A: layering demographics with attitudes
  • 30:32 Q&A: how to know your own supporter mix
  • 32:01 Q&A: should you try to move supporters between segments?
  • 33:17 Q&A: reaching the two-thirds who are not yet supporters
  • 35:02 Q&A: all three segments at once, or staggered?

Full Transcript: Leveraging Donor Empathy Webinar

[00:00] Andrew Spalding: Hey, everyone. Thanks for joining. I’m Andrew Spalding. I’m Creative Director at Fieldtrip. I’ll be moderating today. So without further ado, I’ll turn it over to Jane Pfeiffer.

[00:09] Jane Pfeiffer: Thanks, Andrew. So again, welcome everyone. My name is Jane Pfeiffer, and I’m Founder and President of Fieldtrip. Fieldtrip is a marketing, advertising, and branding agency that’s dedicated to helping nonprofits and purpose-driven organizations reduce their largest expense.

[00:28] Jane Pfeiffer: Now, you might think that this expense lives on the balance sheet somewhere. It’s in your ledger, but it’s not. It’s the cost of IDKs. And I don’t know if you’ve heard of that term before, but an IDK is an I don’t know. So I don’t know you. I don’t know why your mission is important, and I don’t know why solving this social issue impacts my life, because those IDKs create the cost of lost opportunities.

[01:03] Jane Pfeiffer: And that’s really the biggest expense for purpose-driven organizations. So we work with leaders to solve a couple key problems. One is they are frustrated because they feel like they’re the best-kept secret, which makes growth really hard. Or two, they’re worried that what got them to today isn’t sustainable or scalable for what needs to happen in the future, because the world is just changing faster.

[01:31] Jane Pfeiffer: And then finally, and really the topic of our conversation today, is there’s a tremendous gap between the people that the mission supports and then the minds and hearts of the people who can support the mission with time, connection, skills, introductions. And so that creates a really wide gap. And I don’t know if these issues sound like ones that you face, but today we’re really going to dig into that empathy gap and understand what it takes to first understand it and then how to close it and reduce that gap so that our work is more effective.

[02:11] Jane Pfeiffer: So nonprofit fundraising is undergoing a pivotal shift. The public seems less willing than ever to donate, volunteer, raise funds, or advocate for a cause. But is this true? And that’s why we wanted to conduct quantitative research to back up that worry and see what the truth is. So imagine the impact of messaging and communications that can come from nonprofits that forges meaningful connections, breaks down barriers, and fosters empathy. Attitudinal segmentation is that powerful tool. It engages supporters by addressing their unique motivations, their beliefs, and their perceptions around the work that you do.

[02:56] Jane Pfeiffer: So let’s make sure, before we dig into the research results, that we have a really good understanding of attitudinal segmentation. Those are both really big, kind of chunky, beefy words. And let’s actually step out of the nonprofit category and pretend to be retailers for a minute to make sure that we understand what attitudinal segmentation is.

[03:19] Jane Pfeiffer: So this story is true. It comes from our research partner in some of the work they did with a large national candle company. They were upscale and really used fragrances as the means to differentiate themselves from other options. They had a website, catalogs, and then they were also sold through third parties, so department stores and other high-end retailers. They didn’t have dedicated stores themselves, and they would look at marketing and say, okay, we want to target women between the age of 25 and 54 who have a higher-than-average household income and own their own home.

[04:07] Jane Pfeiffer: So when you think about that on a national level, you and I might be able to point to someone who fits that criteria. But how do you advertise and find those people? They’re everywhere, and their lifestyles and choices are really different. So that’s where attitudinal segmentation comes in. It’s focusing on the why behind the decision to buy or the decision to support, rather than the what, how, or demographic characteristics, or characteristics like first-time donor, lapsed donor, recurring donor.

[04:46] Jane Pfeiffer: And this company used attitudes to define three groups and really step away from demographic descriptions. So the first group, self-appreciation, then designer, then gifts. And just like they sound, the self-appreciation was buying the candles based on fragrance. In fact, they were the only one out of the three categories where fragrance was very important. It was all about how they were going to take care of themselves. The candle was used in a routine to create a relaxing setting at home. Whether it was the reward for a hard day’s work or they just wanted a little me time, fragrance here was really important. So they were always buying in stores because they needed to have that smelling experience.

[05:43] Jane Pfeiffer: For the designers, the candle may not ever be lit. It’s really about how the candle finished their spaces and looked the way it did, and created an experience for visitors when they came, and was a personal reflection of that person and how they styled and curated their own home. And then the third category is really focused on the packaging, because they want to convey that this is a high-end luxury item and it’s easy to gift. It comes in a nice package, an elaborate bow, anything that would convey a high quality and make it really simple. So these latter two categories purchased online and catalog because, again, the scent really didn’t matter.

[06:12] Jane Pfeiffer: So the company changed how they went to market to reach the self-appreciation audience. They added scratch-and-sniff strips in their catalog. And in this group alone they saw three x the return. In the designer, they started adding decorating tips and style tips and going on Pinterest to really reach that decor-focused consumer. And then the gifts, again, content was key. They focused on how-to tips for gift giving, packaging, bow tying. And so when you think about any one of these three categories, you can think about content that would be relevant to them and where you might find them.

[07:14] Jane Pfeiffer: Compare that to that same task if you just knew upscale women 25 to 54 who owned a home. What do you want to talk to them about? It’s much more difficult. And so that’s the attitudinal type segmentation that we’re talking about today. And we also found, it was a coincidence, three groups. But let’s talk about the research that we did and how that came together.

[07:43] Jane Pfeiffer: So we wanted to explore the why, the attitudes and feelings behind the reasons people decide to support. So we asked and wanted to solve answers for these questions. What do supporter attitudes reveal that demographics miss? What role does empathy play, and how does empathy impact the decision to give?

[08:07] Jane Pfeiffer: Now, all the respondents that we worked with had made a donation to, volunteered for, or raised funds for a social welfare nonprofit. This data is applicable to nonprofits in any sector, but we did specifically ask questions related to social welfare nonprofits. We had 400 participants from around the United States. This is original quantitative research, and there’s a margin of error of plus or minus 4.9% at a 95% confidence level. And one of the biggest takeaways is there was no significant difference in the three groups in demographics.

[08:51] Jane Pfeiffer: So in the three groups, gender, age, household income, even location like suburban, rural, urban, was consistent across all three groups. So let’s meet the three groups. They split roughly into thirds. You’ll notice this adds up to 101%. That’s just due to rounding. But we have our empathetic supporters, skeptical supporters, and disconnected supporters. Remember, all three of these are supporters, so any category is of interest to us.

[09:28] Jane Pfeiffer: And the defining characteristics is how they think about their motivations to give, the belief in a solution for the issues that nonprofits serve, and then their views on the beneficiaries. And just to be clear, by beneficiaries, we mean the people that benefit from your mission. We tend to call the people who give to your mission the benefactors, and then supporters would also be another way to describe that group. And with supporters, again, we’re talking about donations or volunteering or assisting with fundraising. So of all the people that started the survey, one third of that audience fell into the supporter qualifier and then into these three groups, nearly a third, a third, a third.

[10:24] Jane Pfeiffer: So first, we’ll jump into empathetic supporters. The reasons for giving is that they take a personal responsibility for making a difference in the world, and they have a family of giving. That’s the culture that surrounds them. In the solution, they’re very focused on the belief that a solution is possible. We just need enough people focusing on it, enough commitment, enough funds and the right resources. So they’re optimistic that solutions are possible even for the most complex social issues. Then, when thinking of the beneficiaries, they believe that everyone deserves help, regardless of the decisions and choices they’ve made in their life.

[11:13] Jane Pfeiffer: Each of us may need help at some point in life, and helping someone later in life is as worthwhile as helping earlier. This is a really important point. It means not only helping as an adult versus helping as a child or young adult, but it may also mean helping a person who’s made several wrong decisions and might be on their second or third cycle of needing support. They still believe that the beneficiaries need our support and are worthy.

[11:48] Jane Pfeiffer: So empathetic supporters are optimistic about their potential. They want to be part of the solution. That’s more than giving or donating. It’s playing an important role, and some of the statements that they highly agree with is that it’s a priority to support nonprofits. It’s important work toward making progress on even the most difficult challenges. And even when the issue is unsolvable, they still want to help as long as there’s progress being made.

[12:20] Jane Pfeiffer: When we look to engage the empathetic supporter, it’s not only the quantity of empathetic supporters we want, but the quality of the relationship. How do we move these people from supporting us once, twice, but really becoming our advocates? Because that advocacy is in their DNA. They’re committed and they’re ready to recruit people to help and also donate when they’ve got the right relationship.

[12:51] Jane Pfeiffer: So it requires a distinct combination of external events that, unfortunately, we can’t control, I’ll explain that, and then highly personalized experiences that are within our control. And the interactions with your employees is really important to this group. 57% of them said that they had contact more than twice a year. So that’s high touch. And they want that and they deserve it because of these core beliefs.

[13:19] Jane Pfeiffer: When we think about what encourages the empathetic supporter to make a monetary donation, you can see the first three items, current events, recent experience, and a movie or documentary, are outside of our control. But below that, the stories of a beneficiary, meeting a beneficiary, attending an event for fundraising, or being prompted like a round-up program, those are things that we can focus on and those are really important for this group. You can see how the skeptical and disconnected rate these same criteria, but these are the top-scoring influences for the empathetic donor.

[14:06] Jane Pfeiffer: Now, when we asked this group how can nonprofits create more empathy for their beneficiaries: storytelling. Probably not a surprise answer, but sharing people’s stories. That’s how you reconnect our hearts back to our common humanity. And again, this key focus that we are more similar than we are different. They believe that they could at any moment be the person who’s in need of support.

[14:35] Jane Pfeiffer: And to give you an example of how that might impact messaging, this one you’ll see is a brief testimonial and then that call to action. So saying that a nonprofit saved my life. Without their services, I wouldn’t be on the path to recovery. My future would be hopeless. My kids would be homeless. Getting connected to this nonprofit wasn’t just lucky. It was a miracle. So with this group, we can have the first-person emotional story. And it’s enough because they believe the best in our beneficiaries. And so then we just ask: your dollars create brighter futures for women in our community. Learn how supporters like you drive Sally’s success.

[15:19] Jane Pfeiffer: So let’s get to know the skeptical supporter. The statements that they highly agree with are the external motivators. So, I support nonprofits because my friends and family admire me for doing so. They want to be seen as good and doing the right thing. There is pity involved, and they pity the people in need and feel guilty that they haven’t been helping. As for a solution, they feel like needing help from a nonprofit is usually the result of bad choices. And when thinking about the beneficiaries, people who rely on nonprofits are very different from me. People who rely on nonprofits brought their challenges on themselves. And there is a limit to how much help someone deserves. So again, a lot of personal responsibility for the beneficiaries and then external motivations for their reasons to give.

[16:17] Jane Pfeiffer: So they’re more likely than others to be doubtful that beneficiaries deserve or genuinely need help. These are some of the common statements in this group. I support nonprofits because friends and family admire me. These people are different than me. And, I’ve had experience with the beneficiaries of nonprofits that have made me less likely to support the mission. So where with the empathetic group that was a real strength, here it can be a strength, but it can also backfire. And so how do we cultivate experiences and engage this group? Because even though we see kind of warning flags of thoughts and behaviors, this group is still a supporter. So how do we turn them into supporters for our organization?

[17:09] Jane Pfeiffer: So they have less interest in learning about your organization before they decide to contribute. They are just making that decision, again, because of external factors, whether it’s a recommendation, a death or experience in the family. And they’re more interested in how the money that they give is going to be used than they are in doing the exploratory work up front. You can see that they give less importance to factors like your reputation, your past success, the purpose of your mission, the delivery of services, and other criteria like that. It’s really about making sure that their dollars are not misused.

[17:55] Jane Pfeiffer: So here you can see again with this group the admiration of others, their feelings of guilt and pity. And then they also feel that it’s very difficult to convince others to care. And in large part, that’s a self-reflection, because it’s not saying that they don’t care, but their reasons for caring aren’t as internalized and selfless as we saw with the empathetic group.

[18:24] Jane Pfeiffer: So how can we create more empathy with this skeptical supporter? So share stories from the beneficiary, but don’t sugarcoat it. Don’t keep using the same person or family to cite our success. Otherwise, it’s diluted and supporters can’t understand what people are going through and how many have been helped. Make it clear that whatever beneficiaries are suffering from was not the result of their action or inaction, but was the result of outside influences they had no control over.

[18:58] Jane Pfeiffer: So with the empathetic supporter, we saw in messaging we used a first-person testimonial, a very emotional few sentences, and then a request to help. Here we have to give context to the why that person needs help. So for example, losing your job, it could happen to any of us. For Sally, losing her job meant losing her home and escaping her anxiety through addiction. But the recovery program at blank Nonprofit brought Sally back from the brink. Now she’s one of X number of graduates who makes us a leader in self-driven recovery solutions. So learn how we support women in need and turn bad luck into bright futures.

[19:45] Jane Pfeiffer: So we explain the context of why Sally is struggling with addiction. Yes, there were bad situations and bad choices, but there were also things outside of her control. And we need you, our skeptical supporter, to make this happen again and again.

[20:04] Jane Pfeiffer: Now our disconnected supporter is the toughest to understand. And keep in mind that these three categories are not linear. We’re not trying to move the disconnected supporter to skeptical, to empathetic. These are three unique segments, and we really need to focus on understanding the segments, identifying who in our donor database falls in which attitude, and then how we bring them closer to us based on their motivations and beliefs.

[20:37] Jane Pfeiffer: So with disconnected, they believe it’s important to work towards making progress on even the most difficult challenges, and that no matter what your background and experience, everyone is capable of change. Now this is really important. Capable of change doesn’t mean that everyone from their vantage point is deserving of help, but capable of change. In the solution, they believe that continuous progress is important, and they expect it. And then their view of the beneficiaries: some people will never get out of bad circumstances, no matter how much help they receive. And each of us is always responsible for our decisions and choices.

[21:20] Jane Pfeiffer: So they’re really concerned about the state of the world. Where we saw empathetic want to be the problem solvers, they believe that it could happen to any of us, that we are more alike than different. With the skeptical, it was a more traditional sense of guilt and pity, and I’m a good person if I take care of my less fortunate neighbor. With disconnected, they have a high level of concern about what’s happening in the world, but a little bit of disbelief that solving these complex issues is actually possible, and can nonprofits make progress. So they feel like the problems that they care about may never be solved, and they feel hopeless about the most pressing issues. And it’s that gloom, if you will, that really keeps them from engaging as they might have the potential to do.

[22:19] Jane Pfeiffer: So they’re the least likely, even less likely than empathetic supporters, to give because of external admiration from friends and family. They’re also the group that is most open to convincing others in their social circles to contribute to nonprofits and the causes they support.

[22:38] Jane Pfeiffer: Pity is present in their minds, but empathy can prevail, especially when the beneficiary is not seen as responsible for their plight. We saw a big difference if the beneficiary had been convicted of crimes or seen as, again, making really poor choices, and the disconnected supporter didn’t see the context or complexity that led to making that bad decision or bad situation.

[23:11] Jane Pfeiffer: This segment’s defining trait is that every individual is always responsible, and 80% of disconnected supporters feel the same or less empathetic towards others than ever before. So they’re feeling disconnected not only from your beneficiaries, but from the world, and the hope that we can solve some of these complex issues.

[23:34] Jane Pfeiffer: What encourages this group is very similar to what encourages the empathetic supporter. Then what’s transparent: before they decide to give, they want the organization to be free from scandal, work on solving local issues, spend as much as possible on direct aid, serve the community where I live, and focus on prevention. And you can see the significant difference in the skeptical supporter. Again, they’re not looking as much at learning more about your organization before they donate. They want assurances after they’ve donated that here’s how the money that you gave is going to be used.

[24:15] Jane Pfeiffer: So again, we asked this group, how can we create more empathy in this group? Emphatically, they said, you can’t. Empathy comes within a person. You either have it or you don’t. And it’s not the organization’s responsibility to create empathy. And in this other open-ended answer: there’s a fine line between invoking guilt and empathy. It’s a real turnoff to use guilt, while the latter pulls them in. Real-world examples of the cause-wise problem, and then explaining what they’re doing to mitigate the problems, can help. So here’s where sustainability, scalability, showing the relationship between solving a problem for this person and how it impacts their community, is really important to the disconnected supporter.

[25:04] Jane Pfeiffer: So for example: rehab can be costly and timely for the participant and our town’s social resources. Our nonprofit’s proven substance abuse methods make our town’s economic resources go further and deliver a recovery that lasts. Your gift doesn’t just save lives, it saves the town money by providing hope for Sally and hope for our community. Learn why an investment in our organization is a gift to Sally, your neighbors, and the community.

[25:37] Jane Pfeiffer: So you’ll see, again, it’s that connection of solving a social problem. A substance abuse addiction issue is more than just helping a person. It’s about the ripple effect of what can happen within the community. And we’re inviting them to learn, because they will explore before they make that decision.

[26:00] Jane Pfeiffer: So what do we do with this information? It’s great to have. How do we apply it? Our first goal was to really help you understand the attitudes, and using those message examples as a way that messages would need to appear differently for each attitudinal segment.

[26:18] Jane Pfeiffer: So prioritizing the attitudes of supporters. If you’re lucky, you have good demographic data on your supporter base. You may not even have that. But if you think about the reasons why, even if you can’t partition your database according to these three groups, thinking about the why first, as opposed to the what, meaning what do I want to tell this group? Think about why will they care. That is a great takeaway, and if we do nothing else, that can be very powerful.

[26:56] Jane Pfeiffer: Also, realize that you can apply an attitude and a focus to all groups, whether that’s your employees, your board of directors, your beneficiaries, your policymakers, sponsors, the community at large. Always focusing on the why. And that can be applied, again, to any group.

[27:16] Jane Pfeiffer: Another opportunity is to close the empathy gap, and it varies on how we do this with each group. But here’s some top-line information. So for the empathetic supporter, continuous engagement and turning them into advocates. Giving them the tools, the information, the confidence, and then asking them to become your advocates. This alone is gold. Skeptical supporters: transparency about the context of the issue, its impact, your outcomes, and the obstacles that you and your beneficiaries face. You have to do more explaining and education. And for the disconnected, tell honest and simple stories with layers to allow them to opt in to the type of impact that suits them.

[28:04] Jane Pfeiffer: And what I mean by layers is really thinking about, there’s the Sally story: has a substance abuse disorder and is now in a better place. That’s a powerful story. But for the disconnected, it’s not enough. So we want to talk about the impact of Sally’s recovery to her immediate family. And what’s the impact then to her children in terms of having stable housing, being able to go to the same schools? What’s the impact to an employer, to her neighborhood, to the community, and then to the world that this disconnected supporter lives in?

[28:43] Jane Pfeiffer: Another thing is to assess your supporter base with the segmentation. So that’s also an opportunity to run your database through the profile and see how your donor and supporter group assesses with these three identities. And then finally, digging deeper into the research. We’ll provide a link to the visualization so you can look at most of the questions, look at them by demographic and by these segments, to understand where are the significant differences.

[29:17] Jane Pfeiffer: As we open up for Q&A, I’m going to leave it here on these three segments so that you can have them at your fingertips. And we’ll also include contact information. So if you have more questions after this webinar, we can help you with those as well.

[29:35] Andrew Spalding: When is it appropriate to actually layer in demographics alongside the attitudinal segments?

[29:42] Jane Pfeiffer: Yeah, it’s a great question. In a perfect world we could use attitudinal segmentation and everybody would wear a sweater based on their segment. And it’d be really easy to identify them, but that’s just not realistic. So there isn’t a wrong time for demographics. Unfortunately, there’s not a correlation. So we can’t say men of this age or this criteria fall into each of these segments. So it’s about using both. Looking at your categories like lapsed donors. Well, why are they lapsed? If they’re empathetic, it may be because they don’t feel like they have a significant role in solving the issue. And so I don’t think it’s an either-or, but a yes-and, to use both.

[30:32] Andrew Spalding: How do I know what my specific supporter base looks like?

[30:35] Jane Pfeiffer: Like I said, there is an opportunity to do a survey with your database and find that out specifically. I think what you can do is decide, based on your mission and the obstacles that you’re facing in marketing and communications, then decide where do you want to go. The empathetic supporter, if we could clone them, that’s wonderful. And using messaging that works for the empathetic supporter does not turn off the skeptical and disconnected. It just may not be enough. So looking at more the skeptical and disconnected messaging and some of their motivators won’t deter the empathetic. And that’s probably a better route, just to be more conservative.

[31:20] Jane Pfeiffer: Nonprofit leaders are so strapped for resources, time, skills, employees, money. And what we tend to do is be so general because we are trying to talk to everyone with one email newsletter, one social post. And what we really miss is the so what. So why would people care that I’m talking about this event and that event? So you may not know the specific distribution within your list, but if you can start thinking about the why and using these three groups as a starting place, it’s just that, a starting place.

[32:01] Andrew Spalding: Another question that came up when we first got the results of the research was this question, kind of internally: is the goal to change a supporter from one segment to the other? Are you trying to make a disconnected or skeptical supporter into an empathetic supporter?

[32:18] Jane Pfeiffer: That would be great. But these attitudes and beliefs are rooted in who they were as younger people, who they’ve been surrounded with, their exposure to complex social issues. And so, no, I don’t think it’s a reasonable goal to try and switch disconnected supporters. I would instead focus on getting to know the groups, meet them where they are, and then understand, once you’ve had an emotional connection with them and you’ve provoked some curiosity, you can then tell them more about your organization and bring all these different attitudes closer and tighter in the type of relationship that you have. So it’s more about inviting and getting closer to all three of these groups, as opposed to trying to switch people from one group to another.

[33:17] Andrew Spalding: Should we be thinking about the audience of those who are not in that support bubble, that larger 66% or so that don’t naturally support nonprofits?

[33:27] Jane Pfeiffer: The 66% would likely fall into these three categories. However, they don’t see themselves as supporters. So they’re either engaged infrequently or at such a small level that they just didn’t qualify. They don’t consider themselves to be supporting. We didn’t require a financial amount or frequency amount, but just recent support, being financial or volunteering.

[34:00] Jane Pfeiffer: So I think it’s more of a tactic question than a messaging question. So nonprofits using social media, your events and your email newsletter and maybe print pieces and your impact report, all of those messages are speaking to your current supporters. So you’re working within these three groups. The only way you’re reaching those that aren’t current supporters, or at least aware of you, is when you’re interrupting them in their spaces and places. So is it earned media, public relations? Is it paid advertising or boosted social media posts? Because you have to interrupt them and then provoke some curiosity so they come in. These messages and attitudes will still work for that non-supporter audience, but they’re just likely not aware and not looking for a way to become a supporter.

[35:02] Andrew Spalding: Should we be trying to address all three groups simultaneously, or should we be staggering a variety of communications?

[35:09] Jane Pfeiffer: Yes and yes. And don’t we wish? It’s tough because we don’t have the resources to present three different newsletters and three different social profiles. So the best way I would think about it is when you’re creating a particular communication piece, to think about which of these groups is going to be best served by it. If it is an impact report, well, that’s probably more targeted to your disconnected supporters, because they want to see the proof that you are making progress on solving this problem before they invest.

[35:50] Jane Pfeiffer: So your impact report, use that for disconnected. When it’s your social and it’s brief and photos, that’s where you can tell the brief and emotional stories for your empathetic supporters. You’re going to have to meet skeptical in a completely different place. That might be the place where they show up to your events, because they want to be seen with the right people and the right places. So it’s more about tactic. You can’t create three different types of impact reports, but if you focus on the disconnected, you might be able to also carve out certain pieces within that report that really resonate with the empathetic and skeptical supporters.

[36:30] Andrew Spalding: Thank you again, everyone, for joining us today. We hope you all enjoyed that. And like we said, we’ll be following up with those recordings, links and executive summaries. Thank you everyone for joining.